Avvocati.UsInternational Law Firm Free consultation
Practice areas Business & CorporateReal EstateInheritance & SuccessionAdministrative LawInjury & MalpracticeCross-Border FamilyLitigation & DebtCriminal Defence Fixed-price services The firm Insights Cost planner Contact
WhatsApp us
showing what matters when you are instructing us on behalf of a client

Criminal

Can the US extradite someone from Italy? How the process actually works

17 November 2026

If US authorities want someone who is in Italy, the mechanism is not the European Arrest Warrant you may have read about. The EAW only runs between EU member states. The United States is not one, so Italy and the US extradite under their own bilateral treaty — the 1983 US-Italy Extradition Treaty, updated in 2006 to align with the EU-US extradition agreement. The difference matters: the EAW is built for speed and mutual trust between EU courts; a treaty extradition keeps a judicial check that a US prosecutor cannot skip.

The two channels, and why the distinction matters

A European Arrest Warrant is issued by one EU country's judicial authority and executed almost automatically by another, with very limited grounds to refuse. Treaty extradition between Italy and the US is slower and more adversarial by design: a foreign request has to clear an Italian court before the Ministry of Justice can hand anyone over. If you see "European Arrest Warrant" in something you've read about your own situation and the requesting country is the US, that is the wrong framework — check which one actually applies before you act on advice based on it.

How a US extradition request moves through Italy

  1. The request. The US Department of Justice sends a formal extradition request through diplomatic channels to the Italian Ministry of Justice, with the supporting charges, warrant and evidence the treaty requires.
  2. Provisional arrest, often first. In urgent cases the US can ask Interpol for a Red Notice or ask Italy directly for a provisional arrest, before the full paperwork arrives. Italian police can detain the person on that basis alone for a limited time while the complete request is prepared.
  3. Judicial review. The Corte di Appello (Court of Appeal) in the district where the person is found holds a hearing on whether extradition is legally permissible — not on guilt or innocence. The court checks double criminality (the conduct must be a crime in Italy too), that the treaty's grounds for refusal don't apply, and that the person's rights are respected.
  4. Appeal to the Corte di Cassazione. The Court of Appeal's decision can be challenged before Italy's highest court on points of law.
  5. The final decision rests with the Minister of Justice, who can refuse extradition even after the courts approve it, though not grant it if the courts have refused.

None of this is quick. Realistic timelines run from several months to well over a year when every stage is used.

Grounds that can block extradition

The treaty and Italian constitutional principles give a person facing a US request real arguments, not just delay:

  • Double criminality. If the underlying conduct is not a crime under Italian law, Italy will not extradite for it.
  • Nationality. Italy's constitution restricts extraditing its own citizens for political offenses, and Italian citizenship is a factor courts weigh generally, though it is not an automatic bar for ordinary crimes under the treaty.
  • The death penalty. Italy will not extradite where the sentence sought is death, unless the US gives a binding assurance it will not be imposed or carried out.
  • Political offense exception, narrowly read under the treaty.
  • Statute of limitations under either country's law, depending on the treaty's wording for the specific offense.
  • Human rights grounds, including prison conditions or due process concerns that would make surrender incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.

Whether any of these actually applies is fact-specific and depends on the exact charge, so treat this list as what to ask about, not a conclusion about your own case.

What a European Arrest Warrant does change, if it's really in play

If the request instead comes from another EU country — not the US — the European Arrest Warrant framework genuinely applies, and it is faster: limited grounds to refuse, no full merits review, and typically weeks rather than months. That is the scenario behind warnings like "you could be arrested changing planes in Europe": an EAW outstanding in one EU state can be executed by Italian police even if Italy itself has no interest in the case. If you are unsure which mechanism applies to you, that is the first thing to establish, because the defense strategy is completely different.

While the case is pending

A person held on a provisional arrest or awaiting the Court of Appeal hearing can usually apply for release under conditions — reporting obligations, surrendering a passport — rather than remaining in custody throughout, though this depends on flight risk and the nature of the charge. Legal representation at the provisional-arrest stage, before the first hearing, is the point where the most options still exist.

Where this connects to the rest of an arrest

Extradition only comes up once someone is wanted by a foreign authority rather than by Italy itself. If the arrest is an Italian one from the start, see what actually happens after an arrest in Italy and the role — and the limits — of the US consulate. If charges are already pending in Italy on unrelated conduct, how long an Italian criminal investigation can run sets realistic expectations on timing there too.

Every extradition request turns on its own treaty article, its own charge, and its own procedural history. This is a map of the route, not an assessment of any particular case — that needs a lawyer looking at the actual request.

General information, not advice on your matter. If this is your situation, our criminal defence & extradition page sets out what we do, what it costs you in time, and the documents to have ready. The first consultation is free — tell us what you are dealing with.

Hello.

Tell us what is happening in Italy.
We will tell you what it means.

A free first consultation with a lawyer — not a sales call. In English, at a time that works in your zone.